Describe Relationships Between Events or Concepts
Help Questions
3rd Grade ELA › Describe Relationships Between Events or Concepts
Read the text. In 1955, Rosa Parks would not give up her bus seat. Because of her arrest, many people began the Montgomery Bus Boycott. Then, for over a year, people walked or carpooled instead of riding the buses. As a result, the city lost money and finally changed the bus rules. What was the result of the bus boycott?
People stopped using carpools forever.
Rosa Parks gave up her seat right away.
The buses became airplanes.
The city changed the bus rules.
Explanation
This question tests describing relationships between events, scientific concepts, or procedural steps (CCSS.RI.3.3: Describe the relationship between a series of historical events, scientific ideas or concepts, or steps in technical procedures in a text, using language that pertains to time, sequence, and cause/effect). Students must understand how events, ideas, or steps connect using relationship language. Relationships in informational texts show how events, concepts, or steps connect. Three main types: Time relationships (when things happened - before, after, during, while, at the same time), Sequential relationships (order - first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect relationships (why things happen and what results - because, since, as a result, therefore, causes, leads to). Signal words help readers identify relationships. Understanding these relationships helps readers see how information is organized and connected, not just as isolated facts. In this passage, historical events about the Montgomery Bus Boycott are described. The passage shows cause/effect relationships: Rosa Parks wouldn't give up seat, because of arrest people began boycott, then people walked/carpooled, as a result city lost money and changed rules. Signal words like 'because of,' 'then,' 'as a result,' and 'finally' help show these connections. Choice B is correct because the city changed the bus rules as a result of the boycott. The passage states 'As a result, the city lost money and finally changed the bus rules.' The signal phrase 'as a result' shows this was the effect of the boycott causing financial losses. Choice A is incorrect because Rosa Parks did not give up her seat - this started the whole chain of events. Choice C contradicts the passage which only mentions carpooling during the boycott, not forever. Choice D is not mentioned and doesn't make logical sense. This error occurs when students don't follow cause/effect signal words or misread key details. To help students: Create anchor charts for signal words: Time (before, after, during, while, when, meanwhile), Sequence (first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect (because, since, therefore, as a result, leads to, causes). Teach students to identify signal words while reading and ask 'What does this word tell me about how these ideas connect?' Use graphic organizers: timeline for historical events showing before/after, flowchart for sequential steps with arrows, cause/effect chain with boxes and arrows showing 'this causes that.' Model think-aloud: 'I see as a result - that tells me an effect is coming. So changing bus rules was the result of the boycott.' Practice identifying relationships: Give passage and ask students to circle signal words and explain what relationship each shows. Use sentence frames: 'The boycott caused the city to lose money,' 'Bus rules changed as a result of the boycott.' Teach chronological order with timelines, adding events in sequence. For cause/effect, ask 'Why did this happen?' and 'What happened because of this?' Use real-world examples: recipes (sequence), daily routines (time), science experiments (cause/effect). Watch for: Students who don't notice signal words, confuse before/after, reverse cause and effect, can't identify order of steps, or list events without understanding connections. Provide explicit instruction in each relationship type with multiple examples from different content areas (history, science, procedures).
Read the text. A frog begins as eggs in water. After a few days, tadpoles hatch and swim. Next, the tadpoles grow back legs, and later they grow front legs. Then their tails get shorter while their lungs grow. Finally, the young frog leaves the water. What happened AFTER the tadpoles hatched?
The frog began as eggs in water.
The tadpoles laid eggs in water.
The tadpoles grew back legs.
The young frog left the water.
Explanation
This question tests describing relationships between events, scientific concepts, or procedural steps (CCSS.RI.3.3: Describe the relationship between a series of historical events, scientific ideas or concepts, or steps in technical procedures in a text, using language that pertains to time, sequence, and cause/effect). Students must understand how events, ideas, or steps connect using relationship language. Relationships in informational texts show how events, concepts, or steps connect. Three main types: Time relationships (when things happened - before, after, during, while, at the same time), Sequential relationships (order - first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect relationships (why things happen and what results - because, since, as a result, therefore, causes, leads to). Signal words help readers identify relationships. Understanding these relationships helps readers see how information is organized and connected, not just as isolated facts. In this passage, a scientific process of frog development is described. The passage shows sequential relationships in the life cycle: begins as eggs, tadpoles hatch, next tadpoles grow back legs, later grow front legs, then tails get shorter, finally young frog leaves water. Signal words like 'after,' 'next,' 'later,' 'then,' and 'finally' help show these connections. Choice B is correct because the tadpoles grew back legs after they hatched. The passage indicates that after tadpoles hatch and swim, 'Next, the tadpoles grow back legs.' The word 'next' shows this is the step following hatching, making it what happened after tadpoles hatched. Choice A is incorrect because leaving the water happened at the very end, not right after hatching. Choice C happened before hatching, not after - this reverses the order. Choice D is not mentioned in the passage and doesn't make biological sense as tadpoles don't lay eggs. This error occurs when students don't follow sequential signal words or confuse the order of events. To help students: Create anchor charts for signal words: Time (before, after, during, while, when, meanwhile), Sequence (first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect (because, since, therefore, as a result, leads to, causes). Teach students to identify signal words while reading and ask 'What does this word tell me about how these ideas connect?' Use graphic organizers: timeline for historical events showing before/after, flowchart for sequential steps with arrows, cause/effect chain with boxes and arrows showing 'this causes that.' Model think-aloud: 'I see the word next - that tells me this is the following step. So growing back legs comes after hatching.' Practice identifying relationships: Give passage and ask students to circle signal words and explain what relationship each shows. Use sentence frames: 'Hatching happened before growing legs,' 'Growing back legs is the next step after hatching.' Teach chronological order with timelines, adding events in sequence. For cause/effect, ask 'Why did this happen?' and 'What happened because of this?' Use real-world examples: recipes (sequence), daily routines (time), science experiments (cause/effect). Watch for: Students who don't notice signal words, confuse before/after, reverse cause and effect, can't identify order of steps, or list events without understanding connections. Provide explicit instruction in each relationship type with multiple examples from different content areas (history, science, procedures).
Read the text. In 1620, the Pilgrims arrived in Plymouth. During their first winter, many became sick and hungry. Then the Wampanoag taught them to grow corn and catch fish. After the fall harvest in 1621, the Pilgrims invited the Wampanoag to a feast. Finally, they celebrated for three days. What happened BEFORE the fall harvest in 1621?
The Pilgrims invited the Wampanoag to a feast.
They celebrated for three days.
The Pilgrims built a large parade float.
The Wampanoag taught them to grow corn and fish.
Explanation
This question tests describing relationships between events, scientific concepts, or procedural steps (CCSS.RI.3.3: Describe the relationship between a series of historical events, scientific ideas or concepts, or steps in technical procedures in a text, using language that pertains to time, sequence, and cause/effect). Students must understand how events, ideas, or steps connect using relationship language. Relationships in informational texts show how events, concepts, or steps connect. Three main types: Time relationships (when things happened - before, after, during, while, at the same time), Sequential relationships (order - first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect relationships (why things happen and what results - because, since, as a result, therefore, causes, leads to). Signal words help readers identify relationships. Understanding these relationships helps readers see how information is organized and connected, not just as isolated facts. In this passage, historical events about the Pilgrims and first Thanksgiving are described. The passage shows time relationships: 1620 arrival, first winter sickness, then Wampanoag teaching, after fall harvest 1621 feast, finally three-day celebration. Signal words like 'during,' 'then,' 'after,' and 'finally' help show these connections. Choice B is correct because the Wampanoag taught them to grow corn and fish before the fall harvest. The passage indicates that after the difficult first winter, 'Then the Wampanoag taught them to grow corn and catch fish. After the fall harvest in 1621...' The word 'then' shows this teaching happened before the harvest mentioned next. Choice A is incorrect because celebrating for three days happened after the harvest, not before - the passage says 'Finally, they celebrated for three days.' Choice C also happened after the harvest as the invitation led to the celebration. Choice D is not mentioned in the passage. This error occurs when students don't follow temporal signal words or confuse the order of historical events. To help students: Create anchor charts for signal words: Time (before, after, during, while, when, meanwhile), Sequence (first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect (because, since, therefore, as a result, leads to, causes). Teach students to identify signal words while reading and ask 'What does this word tell me about how these ideas connect?' Use graphic organizers: timeline for historical events showing before/after, flowchart for sequential steps with arrows, cause/effect chain with boxes and arrows showing 'this causes that.' Model think-aloud: 'I see the word then - that tells me this happened next. So the teaching happened before the harvest.' Practice identifying relationships: Give passage and ask students to circle signal words and explain what relationship each shows. Use sentence frames: 'The teaching happened before the harvest,' 'The harvest came after the teaching.' Teach chronological order with timelines, adding events in sequence. For cause/effect, ask 'Why did this happen?' and 'What happened because of this?' Use real-world examples: recipes (sequence), daily routines (time), science experiments (cause/effect). Watch for: Students who don't notice signal words, confuse before/after, reverse cause and effect, can't identify order of steps, or list events without understanding connections. Provide explicit instruction in each relationship type with multiple examples from different content areas (history, science, procedures).
Read the text. First, a student filled a cup with warm water. Then she stirred in sugar until it dissolved. Next, she added yeast, and after 5 minutes bubbles appeared because the yeast began to use the sugar. Finally, she knew the yeast was working. Why did bubbles appear after 5 minutes?
Because she forgot to add any yeast.
Because the water turned into ice.
Because the bubbles caused the yeast to grow.
Because the yeast began to use the sugar.
Explanation
This question tests describing relationships between events, scientific concepts, or procedural steps (CCSS.RI.3.3: Describe the relationship between a series of historical events, scientific ideas or concepts, or steps in technical procedures in a text, using language that pertains to time, sequence, and cause/effect). Students must understand how events, ideas, or steps connect using relationship language. Relationships in informational texts show how events, concepts, or steps connect. Three main types: Time relationships (when things happened - before, after, during, while, at the same time), Sequential relationships (order - first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect relationships (why things happen and what results - because, since, as a result, therefore, causes, leads to). Signal words help readers identify relationships. Understanding these relationships helps readers see how information is organized and connected, not just as isolated facts. In this passage, a scientific experiment with yeast is described. The passage shows both sequence and cause/effect: first filled cup, then stirred sugar, next added yeast, after 5 minutes bubbles appeared because yeast began using sugar, finally knew yeast working. Signal words like 'first,' 'then,' 'next,' 'after,' 'because,' and 'finally' help show these connections. Choice A is correct because the yeast began to use the sugar, causing bubbles. The passage states 'after 5 minutes bubbles appeared because the yeast began to use the sugar.' The word 'because' directly shows that yeast using sugar is the cause of bubble formation. Choice B is incorrect because water turning to ice is not mentioned and would prevent yeast activity. Choice C contradicts the passage which says she added yeast. Choice D reverses the cause and effect - yeast using sugar causes bubbles, not bubbles causing yeast growth. This error occurs when students reverse cause and effect relationships or don't understand the signal word 'because.' To help students: Create anchor charts for signal words: Time (before, after, during, while, when, meanwhile), Sequence (first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect (because, since, therefore, as a result, leads to, causes). Teach students to identify signal words while reading and ask 'What does this word tell me about how these ideas connect?' Use graphic organizers: timeline for historical events showing before/after, flowchart for sequential steps with arrows, cause/effect chain with boxes and arrows showing 'this causes that.' Model think-aloud: 'I see the word because - that tells me a reason is coming. So yeast using sugar is what caused the bubbles.' Practice identifying relationships: Give passage and ask students to circle signal words and explain what relationship each shows. Use sentence frames: 'Bubbles appeared because yeast used sugar,' 'Yeast activity caused bubble formation.' Teach chronological order with timelines, adding events in sequence. For cause/effect, ask 'Why did this happen?' and 'What happened because of this?' Use real-world examples: recipes (sequence), daily routines (time), science experiments (cause/effect). Watch for: Students who don't notice signal words, confuse before/after, reverse cause and effect, can't identify order of steps, or list events without understanding connections. Provide explicit instruction in each relationship type with multiple examples from different content areas (history, science, procedures).
Read the text. Earth is tilted on its axis. Because of this tilt, different places get more direct sunlight at different times of year. When the Northern Hemisphere tilts toward the sun, it is summer there. At the same time, the Southern Hemisphere tilts away and has winter. As Earth orbits the sun, the seasons change. What caused the seasons to change?
Earth’s tilt and its orbit around the sun.
The moon blocking sunlight every day.
Earth getting closer to stars each week.
Clouds staying in the sky all year.
Explanation
This question tests describing relationships between events, scientific concepts, or procedural steps (CCSS.RI.3.3: Describe the relationship between a series of historical events, scientific ideas or concepts, or steps in technical procedures in a text, using language that pertains to time, sequence, and cause/effect). Students must understand how events, ideas, or steps connect using relationship language. Relationships in informational texts show how events, concepts, or steps connect. Three main types: Time relationships (when things happened - before, after, during, while, at the same time), Sequential relationships (order - first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect relationships (why things happen and what results - because, since, as a result, therefore, causes, leads to). Signal words help readers identify relationships. Understanding these relationships helps readers see how information is organized and connected, not just as isolated facts. In this passage, a scientific concept about Earth's seasons is explained. The passage shows cause/effect relationships: Earth is tilted, because of tilt different places get different sunlight, when Northern Hemisphere tilts toward sun it's summer, as Earth orbits seasons change. Signal words like 'because of,' 'when,' and 'as' help show these connections. Choice A is correct because Earth's tilt and its orbit around the sun cause seasons to change. The passage states 'Because of this tilt, different places get more direct sunlight at different times of year' and 'As Earth orbits the sun, the seasons change.' These statements show both the tilt and orbital movement work together to cause seasonal changes. Choice B is incorrect because the moon doesn't block sunlight to cause seasons. Choice C is not mentioned and Earth doesn't get closer to stars. Choice D about clouds is not related to seasonal changes. This error occurs when students don't understand the cause/effect relationship or bring in misconceptions about seasons. To help students: Create anchor charts for signal words: Time (before, after, during, while, when, meanwhile), Sequence (first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect (because, since, therefore, as a result, leads to, causes). Teach students to identify signal words while reading and ask 'What does this word tell me about how these ideas connect?' Use graphic organizers: timeline for historical events showing before/after, flowchart for sequential steps with arrows, cause/effect chain with boxes and arrows showing 'this causes that.' Model think-aloud: 'I see because of - that tells me the tilt causes something. Combined with as Earth orbits, I see two causes working together.' Practice identifying relationships: Give passage and ask students to circle signal words and explain what relationship each shows. Use sentence frames: 'Earth's tilt causes different amounts of sunlight,' 'Seasons change because Earth orbits while tilted.' Teach chronological order with timelines, adding events in sequence. For cause/effect, ask 'Why did this happen?' and 'What happened because of this?' Use real-world examples: recipes (sequence), daily routines (time), science experiments (cause/effect). Watch for: Students who don't notice signal words, confuse before/after, reverse cause and effect, can't identify order of steps, or list events without understanding connections. Provide explicit instruction in each relationship type with multiple examples from different content areas (history, science, procedures).
Read the text. Plants make food in their leaves. When sunlight hits the leaves, it gives energy for photosynthesis. Because of this energy, the plant combines water and carbon dioxide to make sugar. Then the sugar helps the plant grow. Without enough sunlight, the plant cannot make enough food. Why does a plant grow better with more sunlight?
Because the plant turns into a seed right away.
Because the plant stops using water and air.
Because sunlight helps the plant make sugar for energy.
Because sugar blocks the sunlight from the leaves.
Explanation
This question tests describing relationships between events, scientific concepts, or procedural steps (CCSS.RI.3.3: Describe the relationship between a series of historical events, scientific ideas or concepts, or steps in technical procedures in a text, using language that pertains to time, sequence, and cause/effect). Students must understand how events, ideas, or steps connect using relationship language. Relationships in informational texts show how events, concepts, or steps connect. Three main types: Time relationships (when things happened - before, after, during, while, at the same time), Sequential relationships (order - first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect relationships (why things happen and what results - because, since, as a result, therefore, causes, leads to). Signal words help readers identify relationships. Understanding these relationships helps readers see how information is organized and connected, not just as isolated facts. In this passage, a scientific concept about photosynthesis is explained. The passage shows cause/effect relationships: sunlight gives energy, because of energy plant makes sugar, then sugar helps growth, without sunlight plant cannot make food. Signal words like 'when,' 'because of,' 'then,' and 'without' help show these connections. Choice A is correct because sunlight helps the plant make sugar for energy. The passage explains 'When sunlight hits the leaves, it gives energy for photosynthesis. Because of this energy, the plant combines water and carbon dioxide to make sugar. Then the sugar helps the plant grow.' The cause/effect chain shows sunlight enables sugar production which provides energy for growth. Choice B is incorrect because this reverses the relationship - sugar doesn't block sunlight, sunlight helps make sugar. Choice C contradicts the passage which states plants use water and carbon dioxide. Choice D is not mentioned in the passage and doesn't relate to photosynthesis. This error occurs when students reverse cause and effect or don't follow the logical chain of relationships. To help students: Create anchor charts for signal words: Time (before, after, during, while, when, meanwhile), Sequence (first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect (because, since, therefore, as a result, leads to, causes). Teach students to identify signal words while reading and ask 'What does this word tell me about how these ideas connect?' Use graphic organizers: timeline for historical events showing before/after, flowchart for sequential steps with arrows, cause/effect chain with boxes and arrows showing 'this causes that.' Model think-aloud: 'I see because of - that tells me sunlight energy causes something. It causes the plant to make sugar, which then helps growth.' Practice identifying relationships: Give passage and ask students to circle signal words and explain what relationship each shows. Use sentence frames: 'Sunlight causes sugar production,' 'Plants grow because they make sugar from sunlight.' Teach chronological order with timelines, adding events in sequence. For cause/effect, ask 'Why did this happen?' and 'What happened because of this?' Use real-world examples: recipes (sequence), daily routines (time), science experiments (cause/effect). Watch for: Students who don't notice signal words, confuse before/after, reverse cause and effect, can't identify order of steps, or list events without understanding connections. Provide explicit instruction in each relationship type with multiple examples from different content areas (history, science, procedures).
Read the text. A butterfly starts as an egg on a leaf. After a few days, a caterpillar hatches and eats for several weeks. Next, it forms a chrysalis. Inside the chrysalis, it changes into a butterfly. Finally, after about two weeks, the adult butterfly comes out. Which event happened first?
The caterpillar ate for several weeks.
The caterpillar formed a chrysalis.
The adult butterfly came out.
An egg was laid on a leaf.
Explanation
This question tests describing relationships between events, scientific concepts, or procedural steps (CCSS.RI.3.3: Describe the relationship between a series of historical events, scientific ideas or concepts, or steps in technical procedures in a text, using language that pertains to time, sequence, and cause/effect). Students must understand how events, ideas, or steps connect using relationship language. Relationships in informational texts show how events, concepts, or steps connect. Three main types: Time relationships (when things happened - before, after, during, while, at the same time), Sequential relationships (order - first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect relationships (why things happen and what results - because, since, as a result, therefore, causes, leads to). Signal words help readers identify relationships. Understanding these relationships helps readers see how information is organized and connected, not just as isolated facts. In this passage, a scientific process of butterfly metamorphosis is described. The passage shows sequential relationships: starts as egg, after days caterpillar hatches, eats for weeks, next forms chrysalis, changes inside, finally butterfly comes out. Signal words like 'starts,' 'after,' 'next,' and 'finally' help show these connections. Choice C is correct because an egg being laid on a leaf happened first. The passage begins 'A butterfly starts as an egg on a leaf.' The word 'starts' clearly indicates this is the first event in the butterfly life cycle sequence. Choice A is incorrect because forming a chrysalis happens in the middle of the process, after hatching and eating. Choice B occurs at the very end as shown by 'Finally, after about two weeks, the adult butterfly comes out.' Choice D happens after hatching, not first. This error occurs when students don't recognize 'starts' as a signal word indicating the beginning of a sequence. To help students: Create anchor charts for signal words: Time (before, after, during, while, when, meanwhile), Sequence (first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect (because, since, therefore, as a result, leads to, causes). Teach students to identify signal words while reading and ask 'What does this word tell me about how these ideas connect?' Use graphic organizers: timeline for historical events showing before/after, flowchart for sequential steps with arrows, cause/effect chain with boxes and arrows showing 'this causes that.' Model think-aloud: 'I see the word starts - that tells me this is the beginning. So the egg stage comes first.' Practice identifying relationships: Give passage and ask students to circle signal words and explain what relationship each shows. Use sentence frames: 'The butterfly begins as an egg,' 'The egg stage is first.' Teach chronological order with timelines, adding events in sequence. For cause/effect, ask 'Why did this happen?' and 'What happened because of this?' Use real-world examples: recipes (sequence), daily routines (time), science experiments (cause/effect). Watch for: Students who don't notice signal words, confuse before/after, reverse cause and effect, can't identify order of steps, or list events without understanding connections. Provide explicit instruction in each relationship type with multiple examples from different content areas (history, science, procedures).
Read the text. In 1955, Rosa Parks refused to give up her bus seat. Because she was arrested, many people were upset. Then leaders planned the Montgomery Bus Boycott. For 381 days, people walked or carpooled instead of riding buses. Finally, the Supreme Court said bus segregation was illegal, so the boycott ended. What caused the bus boycott to begin?
Rosa Parks was arrested after refusing to move
Buses stopped running in all cities
People walked to school for 381 days
The Supreme Court ended bus segregation
Explanation
This question tests describing relationships between events, scientific concepts, or procedural steps (CCSS.RI.3.3: Describe the relationship between a series of historical events, scientific ideas or concepts, or steps in technical procedures in a text, using language that pertains to time, sequence, and cause/effect). Students must understand how events, ideas, or steps connect using relationship language. Relationships in informational texts show how events, concepts, or steps connect. Three main types: Time relationships (when things happened - before, after, during, while, at the same time), Sequential relationships (order - first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect relationships (why things happen and what results - because, since, as a result, therefore, causes, leads to). Signal words help readers identify relationships. Understanding these relationships helps readers see how information is organized and connected, not just as isolated facts. In this passage, the content describes historical events of the Montgomery Bus Boycott. The passage shows cause-effect and sequential relationships. In 1955 Rosa Parks refused and was arrested, because she was arrested people were upset, then leaders planned boycott, for 381 days people walked, finally Supreme Court ended segregation so boycott ended. Signal words like because, then, for, finally, so help show these connections. Choice C is correct because it explains the cause of the boycott beginning. Her arrest caused people to be upset, which led to planning the boycott. The passage explains 'Because she was arrested, many people were upset. Then leaders planned the Montgomery Bus Boycott,' using 'because.' The signal word 'because' in the passage shows this cause-effect relationship. Choice A is incorrect because it confuses cause with effect. This is the result of the boycott, not the cause - the Supreme Court decision happened finally, after the boycott, as shown by 'Finally, the Supreme Court said... so the boycott ended.' The question asks about what caused it to begin. This error occurs when students reverse cause and effect or confuse order. To help students: Create anchor charts for signal words: Time (before, after, during, while, when, meanwhile), Sequence (first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect (because, since, therefore, as a result, leads to, causes). Teach students to identify signal words while reading and ask 'What does this word tell me about how these ideas connect?' Use graphic organizers: timeline for historical events showing before/after, flowchart for sequential steps with arrows, cause/effect chain with boxes and arrows showing 'this causes that.' Model think-aloud: 'I see the word because - that tells me a reason is coming. So [cause] is what made [effect] happen.' Practice identifying relationships: Give passage and ask students to circle signal words and explain what relationship each shows. Use sentence frames: '[Event] happened before [event],' '[Step] is the first step because,' '[Cause] caused [effect].' Teach chronological order with timelines, adding events in sequence. For cause/effect, ask 'Why did this happen?' and 'What happened because of this?' Use real-world examples: recipes (sequence), daily routines (time), science experiments (cause/effect). Watch for: Students who don't notice signal words, confuse before/after, reverse cause and effect, can't identify order of steps, or list events without understanding connections. Provide explicit instruction in each relationship type with multiple examples from different content areas (history, science, procedures).
Read the text. First, Mia poured cream into a jar. Then she shook it for 10 minutes because shaking makes the fat stick together. After that, butter formed and liquid separated. Finally, she poured off the liquid and rinsed the butter. What was the result of shaking the jar?
The jar became empty before shaking.
The butter formed and liquid separated.
Mia poured cream into a jar.
Mia rinsed the butter with cold water.
Explanation
This question tests describing relationships between events, scientific concepts, or procedural steps (CCSS.RI.3.3: Describe the relationship between a series of historical events, scientific ideas or concepts, or steps in technical procedures in a text, using language that pertains to time, sequence, and cause/effect). Students must understand how events, ideas, or steps connect using relationship language. Relationships in informational texts show how events, concepts, or steps connect. Three main types: Time relationships (when things happened - before, after, during, while, at the same time), Sequential relationships (order - first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect relationships (why things happen and what results - because, since, as a result, therefore, causes, leads to). Signal words help readers identify relationships. Understanding these relationships helps readers see how information is organized and connected, not just as isolated facts. In this passage, a technical procedure for making butter is described. The passage shows both sequence and cause/effect relationships. First Mia poured cream, then she shook it because shaking makes fat stick together, after that butter formed and liquid separated, finally she poured off liquid and rinsed butter. Signal words like 'because' and 'after that' help show these connections. Choice A is correct because it identifies the result of shaking the jar. The passage states 'she shook it for 10 minutes because shaking makes the fat stick together. After that, butter formed and liquid separated.' The word 'because' shows shaking caused fat to stick together, and 'after that' shows the result was butter forming and liquid separating. Choice B is incorrect because this was the first step, not a result of shaking. Choice C happened after the butter formed, not as a result of shaking. Choice D is not mentioned in the passage and doesn't make logical sense. This error occurs when students don't follow the cause/effect signal words or confuse sequence with results. To help students: Create anchor charts for signal words: Time (before, after, during, while, when, meanwhile), Sequence (first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect (because, since, therefore, as a result, leads to, causes). Teach students to identify signal words while reading and ask 'What does this word tell me about how these ideas connect?' Use graphic organizers: timeline for historical events showing before/after, flowchart for sequential steps with arrows, cause/effect chain with boxes and arrows showing 'this causes that.' Model think-aloud: 'I see the word because - that tells me a reason is coming. So shaking is what made the butter form.' Practice identifying relationships: Give passage and ask students to circle signal words and explain what relationship each shows. Use sentence frames: 'Shaking caused butter to form,' 'This happened because of shaking.' Teach chronological order with timelines, adding events in sequence. For cause/effect, ask 'Why did this happen?' and 'What happened because of this?' Use real-world examples: recipes (sequence), daily routines (time), science experiments (cause/effect). Watch for: Students who don't notice signal words, confuse before/after, reverse cause and effect, can't identify order of steps, or list events without understanding connections. Provide explicit instruction in each relationship type with multiple examples from different content areas (history, science, procedures).
Read the text. In 1903, the Wright brothers tested their flying machine. Before that, they studied how birds glide and built many kites. During the tests, they changed the wings so the plane could turn. Later that year, they flew at Kitty Hawk for 12 seconds. As a result, people saw that powered flight was possible. Which event happened first?
They changed the wings so the plane could turn
They studied birds and built many kites
People saw that powered flight was possible
They flew at Kitty Hawk for 12 seconds
Explanation
This question tests describing relationships between events, scientific concepts, or procedural steps (CCSS.RI.3.3: Describe the relationship between a series of historical events, scientific ideas or concepts, or steps in technical procedures in a text, using language that pertains to time, sequence, and cause/effect). Students must understand how events, ideas, or steps connect using relationship language. Relationships in informational texts show how events, concepts, or steps connect. Three main types: Time relationships (when things happened - before, after, during, while, at the same time), Sequential relationships (order - first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect relationships (why things happen and what results - because, since, as a result, therefore, causes, leads to). Signal words help readers identify relationships. Understanding these relationships helps readers see how information is organized and connected, not just as isolated facts. In this passage, the content describes historical events about the Wright brothers' invention. The passage shows time and cause-effect relationships. They studied birds and built kites before testing in 1903, during tests they changed wings, later they flew for 12 seconds, as a result people saw powered flight was possible. Signal words like before, during, later, as a result help show these connections. Choice C is correct because it identifies the earliest event in the time sequence. The passage indicates that they studied birds and built many kites before the 1903 tests. The text states 'Before that, they studied how birds glide and built many kites.' The signal word 'before' in the passage shows this time relationship. Choice A is incorrect because it describes a later event, not the first. This event happened later that year, after the studying and testing, as shown by 'Later that year.' The question asks about which event happened first. This error occurs when students confuse order or don't understand temporal relationships. To help students: Create anchor charts for signal words: Time (before, after, during, while, when, meanwhile), Sequence (first, next, then, finally, last), Cause/Effect (because, since, therefore, as a result, leads to, causes). Teach students to identify signal words while reading and ask 'What does this word tell me about how these ideas connect?' Use graphic organizers: timeline for historical events showing before/after, flowchart for sequential steps with arrows, cause/effect chain with boxes and arrows showing 'this causes that.' Model think-aloud: 'I see the word because - that tells me a reason is coming. So [cause] is what made [effect] happen.' Practice identifying relationships: Give passage and ask students to circle signal words and explain what relationship each shows. Use sentence frames: '[Event] happened before [event],' '[Step] is the first step because,' '[Cause] caused [effect].' Teach chronological order with timelines, adding events in sequence. For cause/effect, ask 'Why did this happen?' and 'What happened because of this?' Use real-world examples: recipes (sequence), daily routines (time), science experiments (cause/effect). Watch for: Students who don't notice signal words, confuse before/after, reverse cause and effect, can't identify order of steps, or list events without understanding connections. Provide explicit instruction in each relationship type with multiple examples from different content areas (history, science, procedures).